Regulators and what they can impose
The Federal Trade Commission polices deceptive advertising nationwide, but its power to collect money is narrower than many businesses assume. Civil penalties are generally tied to violating an existing FTC order or a trade regulation rule, such as the rule on fake reviews and testimonials, or to conduct the agency has already put the industry on notice about. The Supreme Court has also limited one of the FTC's main court routes for recovering consumer refunds, which pushed the agency toward rules and orders. State attorneys general can often seek injunctions, restitution, and civil penalties under their own statutes. New York's FAIR Business Practices Act, effective in 2026, gives the Attorney General reach over unfair and abusive practices as well as deceptive ones. Some states, New York among them, also have a criminal false advertising provision, though it is seldom the main concern for a business.
The substantiation file and the campaign record
Regulators usually start by asking what support existed for the claim when it first ran. Pull together the testing, studies, surveys, or data behind each challenged statement, with dates showing when they were obtained. Keep drafts, approval emails, influencer agreements, and records of where and when the ads appeared. Sales and refund figures for the product may be requested, since they bear on restitution. Turn off auto-deletion for the marketing team and agency accounts involved. If you decide to revise or pull a claim, do so deliberately and keep the earlier versions rather than overwriting them.
Sizing the exposure and the response
We begin by identifying who is involved: a federal agency, a state office, a competitor under the Lanham Act, a consumer class, or a self-regulatory challenge before BBB National Programs. Each has different remedies and different procedures, and a single campaign can draw more than one. We review the claim against the substantiation and look for statements that are clearly defensible, those that need narrowing, and those better withdrawn. Responses to investigative demands have their own deadlines and scope negotiations. Early cooperation, compliance changes, and the way a resolution is worded can all affect what follows, including later private suits.






