How the penalty is framed
Non-willful penalties apply when a U.S. person failed to file required FBARs without intending to violate the law. The Supreme Court has held that the non-willful penalty is assessed per annual report rather than per account, so the count of violations follows the years, not the number of accounts listed. The statutory maximum per report is adjusted for inflation, and examiners may propose less under internal guidelines, which also cap the total across the years examined. A reasonable-cause exception can eliminate the penalty when the statute's conditions are met. Those boundaries define most of the negotiation.
Building the reasonable-cause case
Reasonable cause looks at the whole picture: your education and background, whether you relied on a tax professional who knew about the accounts, how the accounts came to exist, and whether you acted promptly once you learned of the requirement. Inherited accounts, accounts opened for you as a child, and accounts in a country where you once lived are common settings. Helpful evidence includes engagement letters or questionnaires from your preparer, correspondence showing what you were told, and records of when you learned about the obligation. Statements should be truthful and consistent with what the IRS already has, including information foreign banks report under information-sharing agreements.
Before the penalty is assessed
You can usually ask the IRS Independent Office of Appeals to review a proposed non-willful FBAR penalty, and doing so before assessment keeps more options open. If the examiner asks you to extend the time to assess, that request deserves analysis rather than an automatic signature. We review the examiner's report, the years and accounts counted, and how the proposed amount was calculated against the guidelines. Then we decide whether to argue reasonable cause, challenge the count or the amount, or negotiate a resolution, and we coordinate the FBAR issue with any income tax adjustments for the same years.






