1. Does the Case Qualify for the Commercial Division?

Under 22 NYCRR § 202.70, assignment depends on the dispute's subject matter, monetary value, and filing requirements. Not every business dispute qualifies.
Check the $100,000 Threshold
Westchester County generally requires $100,000 in controversy, excluding punitive damages, interest, costs, disbursements, and claimed attorney fees.
Eligible matters include commercial contracts, business fraud, fiduciary-duty claims, and Uniform Commercial Code transactions. Shareholder derivative actions, commercial class actions, and specified business dissolution proceedings are exempt from the monetary threshold.
For equitable or declaratory relief, courts measure the value of the intended benefit, protected right, or avoided injury, whichever is greatest. An attorney assessing commercial litigation must also confirm that the claim qualifies under § 202.70(b).
Request Assignment within 90 Days
Under § 202.70(d), parties generally must request assignment within 90 days after service of the complaint by filing a Request for Judicial Intervention (RJI) with a Commercial Division Addendum.
Section 202.70(e) permits a late-transfer application to the Administrative Judge, on notice to the parties, upon a showing of good cause. The assignment deadline differs from the defendant's response deadline.
2. Which Filing and Motion Rules Apply?
Commercial Division cases follow the CPLR, statewide rules, and the assigned judge's Part Rules. Electronic filing does not necessarily satisfy service requirements.
Verify NYSCEF and Filing Requirements
Westchester Commercial Division cases generally use NYSCEF, subject to applicable exceptions. Attorneys must verify service procedures and court-specific filing instructions.
Under Rule 21, courtesy copies generally should not be submitted unless requested or otherwise required. Cases using the court's Filing by Electronic Means System require courtesy copies of motion papers and proposed orders.
The business litigation attorney guide separately addresses initial service and response obligations under New York law.
Follow Pre-Motion Procedures
Rule 24 generally requires a written pre-motion conference request of no more than two pages, with notice to opposing attorneys.
Exceptions include specified CPLR 3211, 3212, and 3213 motions made when the RJI is filed or after discovery is complete. Discovery disputes follow Rule 14 instead.
Business litigation attorneys can assess the applicable procedure before filing a motion.
3. How Are Discovery Deadlines Managed?
Commercial Division conferences establish case-specific schedules for evidence production, depositions, and motions. Initial disclosure obligations may arise before the preliminary conference.
Prepare for the Preliminary Conference
Rule 7 generally requires a preliminary conference within 45 days after assignment, or as soon afterward as practicable. When an RJI accompanies a dispositive motion, different timing applies.
Rule 8 requires advance consultation about discovery and settlement. Under Rule 11-h, parties generally must disclose specified witnesses, documents, and damages calculations within 14 days after that consultation, subject to stipulated changes, court orders, or applicable objections.
Resolve Discovery Disputes under Rule 14
Rule 14 generally requires a thorough, good-faith attempt to resolve disclosure disputes before requesting court intervention, absent exigent circumstances or different Part Rules.
Unresolved disputes ordinarily require a conference-request letter of no more than three single-spaced pages, with certification of the consultation or good cause for its absence.
Under Rule 15, postponing a conference does not automatically extend subsequent dates in the preliminary conference order.
4. When Does a Commercial Case Enter Mediation?
The Ninth Judicial District operates a presumptive mediation program for qualifying commercial disputes. Participation does not require the parties to reach a settlement.
Identify Cases Eligible for Mediation
Eligible matters include certain closely held business disputes, restrictive covenants, unfair competition, construction, banking, commercial insurance, and commercial real estate claims, excluding real estate cases involving Yellowstone injunctions.
Cases involving less than twice the Commercial Division monetary threshold may also qualify. Other matters may be referred by party agreement or judicial direction.
Under Rule 10, attorneys must submit ADR certification at the preliminary conference and subsequent compliance or status conferences.
Keep Mediation and Court Deadlines Separate
Referred parties must follow the mediation order and program rules. Companies should confirm settlement authority and required corporate approvals before reaching an agreement.
Mediation does not automatically suspend discovery or motion deadlines. Schedule changes require appropriate court authorization.
The mediation and ADR page explains alternative dispute resolution methods.
18 Nov, 2026

