1. Can a Broken Business Promise Prove Criminal Fraud?
A broken promise alone cannot establish larceny by false promise. Prosecutors must prove that the defendant obtained property through a fraudulent promise and satisfy New York's special evidentiary requirement.
Apply New York's False-Promise Evidence Rule
Under Penal Law § 155.05(2)(d), larceny by false promise involves obtaining another person's property through a scheme to defraud based on a promise of future conduct that the defendant did not intend to perform or did not believe a third party intended to perform.
Nonperformance alone cannot establish the required intent or belief. The evidence must be wholly consistent with guilty intent or belief, wholly inconsistent with innocent intent or belief, and exclude innocent explanations to a moral certainty.
This special rule does not govern every fraud offense.
Separate Original Intent from Later Business Failure
A company may lose expected financing, supplies, or regulatory approval after entering an agreement. Such developments do not establish that its original promise was fraudulent.
Documented efforts to fulfill the agreement may challenge allegations of an existing intent not to perform.
2. Which Records Can Establish Intent When the Promise Was Made?
Contemporaneous records may show what the defendant knew when obtaining money or property. Their dates and contents help distinguish earlier expectations from later explanations.
Examine Negotiation Records and Available Resources
Relevant evidence includes:
- Signed agreements and dated proposals.
- Financing applications and bank correspondence.
- Supplier commitments and purchase orders.
- Messages describing known performance limitations.
A financing rejection after an agreement differs from evidence that the defendant knew funding was unavailable when making the promise.
Compare Payment Use with Contractual Restrictions
When an agreement restricts how funds may be spent, compare those terms with bank transfers and expenditures.
An unauthorized transfer may support an inference of improper intent, but its timing and circumstances matter. The transfer alone does not establish larceny by false promise.
3. Which Criminal Charges Can Arise from the Transaction?
Larceny by false promise, scheme to defraud, and federal wire fraud involve different elements. The charged offense determines what prosecutors must prove.
Distinguish Larceny from a Scheme to Defraud
Penal Law § 155.05 recognizes larceny by false promise. A grand larceny charge requires an additional qualifying felony circumstance, such as the property's value or type.
Penal Law § 190.60 addresses a systematic, ongoing scheme intended to defraud or obtain property from more than one person, resulting in property obtained from at least one.
Under § 190.65(1), first-degree alternatives include schemes targeting ten or more people and obtaining property from at least one, or schemes targeting more than one person and obtaining property exceeding $1,000. Other statutory alternatives also apply.
These offenses require proof of a qualifying continuing scheme.
Identify When Federal Wire Fraud May Apply
Under 18 U.S.C. § 1343, wire fraud generally requires a scheme to obtain money or property through material deception, intent to defraud, and qualifying interstate or foreign wire communications furthering the scheme.
In Kousisis v. United States (2025), the Supreme Court held that fraudulent inducement involving money or property may support federal fraud liability without an intent to cause economic loss.
A wire fraud prosecution follows federal requirements rather than New York's special false-promise evidence rule.
4. How Do Civil Claims and Criminal Proceedings Differ?

A disputed transaction may lead to civil litigation, criminal prosecution, or both. Each proceeding has separate elements, proof requirements, and consequences.
Separate Civil Fraud from Criminal Proof
New York common-law fraud generally requires a material misrepresentation, knowledge of falsity, intent to induce reliance, justifiable reliance, and resulting injury.
CPLR § 3016(b) requires fraud allegations to be pleaded with particularity. Criminal charges require proof of every offense element beyond a reasonable doubt.
A business fraud attorney guide discusses civil claims and remedies. A civil settlement does not automatically terminate criminal prosecution.
Identify the Court and Applicable Procedure
Felony cases arising in Westchester County generally proceed in County Court, although Supreme Court also has criminal jurisdiction under New York law.
Federal charges may proceed in the Southern District of New York, whose White Plains Division handles criminal matters arising primarily in Westchester and nearby counties.
The charging document and court assignment determine the applicable procedures and deadlines.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
Does Repaying the Money End a Fraud Investigation?
Not necessarily. Repayment may affect restitution or negotiations but does not automatically erase a completed offense.
Its timing may also matter, particularly when repayment occurred before an investigation began.
Can a Business Officer Face Charges Without Personally Receiving the Money?
Yes. Personal receipt is not required for every fraud offense. Liability depends on the individual's conduct and the applicable criminal elements.
A corporate title or approval signature alone does not establish guilt. A corporate fraud investigation may distinguish individual participation from company activity.
6. Reviewing False-Promise Allegations in Westchester County
A business officer facing criminal allegations may need to examine the original representations, available resources, and evidence supporting or contradicting the alleged fraudulent intent.
SJKP LLP can review transaction records, assess the charged offenses, and evaluate responses to investigations or formal proceedings.
18 Nov, 2026

