1. What Happens after an Albany Criminal Appeal Is Filed?

The court that entered the judgment generally determines the appellate route. Filing a notice of appeal begins the process, but further submissions are needed before appellate review.
Confirm the Reviewing Court and Notice Deadline
Criminal appeals from Albany County Court or the New York Supreme Court in Albany County generally go to the Appellate Division, Third Department. Appeals from Albany City Court ordinarily go to Albany County Court.
Under CPL § 460.10(1), a defendant generally must file a notice of appeal with the original court and serve the District Attorney within 30 days after sentencing. Appeals from separate orders and certain local court proceedings follow different requirements.
Obtain Counsel and Transcripts
A defendant may retain an appellate attorney or seek assigned representation if eligible.
Under 22 NYCRR § 850.11(a), a court-granted waiver of costs, fees, and expenses allows the appellant to obtain specified transcripts and relevant records through the originating court clerk after the required decision is served.
Missing materials should be identified before preparing the record and brief for a criminal appeal.
2. What Records Does the Third Department Require?
The Third Department applies 22 NYCRR Parts 1245 and 1250 alongside its supplemental rules in Part 850. The method used to perfect an appeal determines the required submissions.
Identify the Required Record and Appendix
Under § 850.11(e), a criminal appeal appendix must include the indictment and complete sentencing minutes, along with materials required by § 1250.7(d).
Additional records depend on the issues raised. A suppression challenge may require the relevant hearing transcript and ruling.
Verify Electronic Filing Requirements
Under § 850.5(2), Third Department cases generally require NYSCEF filing, subject to specified exemptions. Section 850.9 also governs applicable hard-copy and digital submissions.
Under § 850.5(3), an appendix is unnecessary when the original-record method applies, electronic filing is mandatory, and the entire appellate record has been electronically filed. The briefs must then cite that record.
3. What Happens If a Criminal Appeal Is Not Perfected?
An unfinished appeal may require an extension to submit the record and brief. Court-ordered perfection deadlines and the Third Department's abandonment rule impose separate requirements.
Request Additional Time to Perfect
Under § 850.11(b), an appellant may request an extension by letter, on notice to all parties, when the court has set a perfection date.
Assigned counsel must proceed by motion when requesting an extension more than one year after assignment.
The request must identify the judgment and notice dates, conviction by trial or plea, bail status, transcript and record status, reason for delay, and anticipated completion date. Proof of service on the District Attorney and defendant is required.
Address the 24-Month Abandonment Rule
Under § 850.11(d), a CPL-authorized appeal is deemed abandoned if the appellant fails to make the specified application for a waiver of costs, fees, and expenses or assignment of counsel, or fails to perfect the appeal within 24 months after the notice-of-appeal date.
After that period, the clerk cannot accept the record, brief, or appendix without a court order.
Relief requires a motion on notice supported by an affidavit explaining a reasonable excuse for the delay and providing the information required by § 850.11(b). The 24-month rule does not override an earlier court-ordered deadline.
4. How Do Sentence-Only Appeals Differ?
An appeal challenging only the legality, propriety, or excessiveness of a sentence may qualify for a shortened record. Appeals also challenging the conviction follow different requirements.
Use the Shortened Sentencing Record
Under § 850.11(f), a sentence-only appeal may proceed on the notice of appeal, sentencing minutes, and plea minutes when applicable.
The record must be labeled "Record on Appeal from Sentence," include a CPLR § 5531 statement, and be stipulated to or settled. A copy of the presentence report must also be filed with the clerk.
Check Oral Argument Restrictions
Under § 850.15(c), oral argument generally is unavailable in sentence-only appeals unless the court permits it.
When an appeal also challenges the conviction, issues involving unpreserved trial errors may require separate analysis under CPL § 470.05(2).
5. Reviewing Third Department Appeal Requirements
An unfinished appeal requires examination of its filing history, available transcripts, required submissions, and applicable deadlines.
SJKP LLP can review notices of appeal, court orders, transcripts, and appellate filings to assess procedural requirements and available options under New York law.
16 Nov, 2026

