1. Does the Remaining Occupant Have a Right to Stay?
The original occupancy arrangement determines whether the resident may continue living in the apartment. A person named on the lease has different rights from someone who entered with another tenant's permission.
Separate Tenants from Permitted Roommates
Real Property Law § 235-f generally permits tenants to live with immediate family and an additional occupant, subject to statutory conditions. Under § 235-f(6), an occupant does not acquire continuing tenancy rights through that provision after the named tenant vacates without the landlord's express written permission. Separate rights may still exist. A person named on the lease remains a tenant, while an eligible family member may qualify for succession. The roommate law framework explains the general rules for shared occupancy.
Distinguish a License from a Sublease
A license permits occupancy without transferring an independent possessory estate. A sublease may grant exclusive possession of defined premises for an agreed period. The parties' intentions and actual arrangements determine the classification. In Field v. Pinto (2026), Kings County Housing Court found that roommates without exclusive possession of a defined space were licensees. Financial contributions alone did not establish a tenancy. The petitioner was the named tenant seeking to remove roommates, not a property owner acting after departure.
2. Can Rent Stabilization Preserve Occupancy Rights?
Rent-stabilized housing may provide succession rights after the named tenant permanently leaves. Owners must examine those rights before treating a remaining resident as a licensee.
Apply the Family Succession Requirements
Under 9 NYCRR § 2523.5(b), a qualifying family member generally must have shared the apartment as a primary residence for two years before permanent departure. The period is generally one year for a qualifying senior citizen or person with a disability. Shorter qualifying relationships or tenancies may satisfy the rule from their inception. Family status may include a nontraditional relationship involving emotional and financial commitment and interdependence under § 2520.6(o). The NYC rent stabilization page explains the broader regulatory framework.
Establish Departure and the Required Residence Period
Continued rent payments or renewal leases signed by the departing tenant do not necessarily defeat succession under § 2523.5(b)(2). Records should establish when the tenant permanently left and whether the claimant maintained the apartment as a primary residence.
| Question | Relevant Records |
|---|---|
| Who holds the lease? | Lease and renewals |
| When did the tenant leave? | Surrender letters, moving records |
| Did the claimant reside there? | Identification, tax and address records |
| Is the relationship qualifying? | Family and shared financial records |
Who holds the lease?
- Relevant RecordsLease and renewals
When did the tenant leave?
- Relevant RecordsSurrender letters, moving records
Did the claimant reside there?
- Relevant RecordsIdentification, tax and address records
Is the relationship qualifying?
- Relevant RecordsFamily and shared financial records
Recognized temporary absences, including education or hospitalization, may not interrupt the qualifying period under § 2523.5(b)(3). The person asserting succession generally bears the burden of proving eligibility.
3. When Is a Licensee Holdover Appropriate?

RPAPL § 713(7) permits a proceeding when a qualifying license has expired, the licensor revoked it, or the licensor no longer has the right to possession. The owner must establish the applicable ground rather than rely on the occupant's absence from the lease.
Verify the Ten-Day Notice Requirement
A licensee holdover generally requires a ten-day notice to quit served under RPAPL § 735. The owner must determine what ended the permission and whether the former tenant retains legal possession. Moving out does not necessarily terminate a lease. Check surrender records and any separate agreement with the occupant. Ordinary nonpayment notice requirements are addressed in the New York eviction lawyer guide.
Match the Petition to the Occupancy Relationship
Under RPAPL § 741, the petition must identify the petitioner's interest, the respondent's relationship to the property, and the grounds for removal. Confirm:
- Who originally granted occupancy permission.
- Whether the license expired or was revoked.
- Whether independent tenancy or succession rights exist.
- Whether the notice and service support the claim.
A person cannot be classified as a licensee solely because the petition uses that term. If the facts establish a tenancy, a different proceeding or additional notices may be required.
4. What If the Occupant Refuses to Leave?
An occupant without continuing tenancy rights may still receive protection against unlawful physical removal. The owner must obtain legal authority before recovering possession.
Avoid Unlawful Lockouts
RPAPL § 768 generally protects people who lawfully occupied a dwelling for at least 30 consecutive days or entered into a lease against unlawful eviction. NYC Administrative Code § 26-521 provides additional local protections. Thirty days of residence does not automatically create a tenancy. However, changing locks, removing belongings, or interrupting essential services to force departure may violate these laws.
Obtain a Warrant before Removal
After a judgment awarding possession, an authorized marshal or sheriff executes the eviction warrant. RPAPL § 749 generally requires at least 14 days' written notice before execution, separate from the earlier ten-day notice to quit. Execution generally occurs on a business day between sunrise and sunset. An outstanding stay or later court order may prevent enforcement.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
Must a Tenant Tell the Landlord When a Roommate Moves In?
Under RPL § 235-f(5), a tenant must inform the landlord of an occupant's name within 30 days after occupancy begins or within 30 days after the landlord requests that information. Failure to disclose a roommate does not automatically establish grounds for a licensee holdover.
Does Failure to Disclose a Family Member Defeat Succession?
Not automatically. Under 9 NYCRR § 2523.5(e), a tenant may identify potential successors, and an owner may request information within regulatory limits. A person seeking succession must still prove the qualifying relationship and required residence.
6. Review Remaining Occupant Rights with SJKP LLP
When a tenant leaves but another resident remains, SJKP LLP's attorneys can review the lease, surrender records, occupancy arrangements, succession claims, and RPAPL § 713(7) requirements to assess the appropriate possession proceeding.
17 Nov, 2026

