1. Which Contract Documents Control the Allegation?
The contracting agency and procurement terms establish the contractor's obligations. County, municipal, state, and federal agreements may impose different requirements.
Identify the Agency and Procurement Rules
Westchester County publishes requests for proposals and qualifications, while its Bureau of Purchase and Supplies manages separate purchasing bids.
The solicitation, amendments, award documents, and signed agreement establish the relevant government contracts obligations.
Review Bid Certifications
New York General Municipal Law §103-d requires non-collusive certifications for covered bids and proposals where competitive bidding is legally required.
These certifications address independent pricing, improper disclosures, and efforts to restrict competition. Bid communications may reveal whether the statements were accurate.
2. When Can a Contract Dispute Support Fraud Liability?
Contractual nonperformance does not alone establish fraud. The disputed representation and the contractor's knowledge must satisfy the applicable legal requirements.
Identify the Disputed Representation
Allegations may concern bidder qualifications, available equipment, completed work, or billing quantities.
Original submissions help establish whether a statement was false when made. Later nonperformance does not, by itself, prove an earlier fraudulent representation.
Examine Knowledge and Supporting Records
Billing discrepancies may arise from measurement errors, disputed terms, or knowing overstatements.
Certifications, payment applications, inspection reports, and emails can identify who supplied disputed information and when.
A procurement fraud allegation must satisfy the elements of the applicable civil claim or criminal offense.
3. How Do Change Orders Affect False Claims Liability?
An approved change in scope or price may support additional billing. The contract and authorized modifications determine the basis for payment.
Compare Approvals and Invoices
A signed change order may authorize additional work, while an informal instruction may not satisfy contractual approval requirements.
Compare approval dates, revised pricing, invoices, and completed work. Subcontractor records may help verify disputed quantities.
Identify the Applicable False Claims Act
New York State Finance Law §189 covers specified false claims involving state or local government interests. The federal False Claims Act, 31 U.S.C. §3729, covers qualifying federal payment claims.
For principal knowing-false-claim violations, both laws recognize actual knowledge, deliberate ignorance, and reckless disregard without requiring specific intent to defraud. The statutory claim requirements and materiality must also be assessed. A New York False Claims Act defense should examine the disputed submission and the contractor's knowledge.
4. What Should a Contractor Check during an Investigation?

Audits, civil investigative demands, and criminal investigations involve different procedures. The initiating document determines the immediate response obligations.
Distinguish Civil and Criminal Exposure
Civil false-claims liability differs from criminal prosecution, which requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
New York Penal Law §155.05 addresses larceny. Federal wire fraud under 18 U.S.C. §1343 requires a fraudulent scheme and qualifying interstate or foreign wire communications used to advance it.
Contract termination and administrative remedies may arise separately.
Review the Request and Preserve Records
County, state, or federal authorities may investigate conduct within their jurisdiction. Westchester County falls within the Southern District of New York.
Before responding, verify the issuing authority, production deadline, document scope, and available objections. Preserve original records and electronic approvals.
Broader government fraud investigations in New York may also raise privilege and individual-liability issues.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Company Officer Be Personally Liable?
Yes, if the officer's conduct satisfies the applicable legal requirements. Corporate status alone does not establish liability, but personal participation and knowledge may matter.
Does Correcting an Invoice Eliminate Liability?
Not necessarily. Correcting an invoice does not erase an earlier knowing false claim. The correction's timing and supporting records may affect the assessment.
6. Reviewing Government Contractor Fraud Allegations
A disputed certification, payment claim, or investigative demand requires identifying the alleged misconduct and applicable legal obligations.
SJKP LLP can review contract approvals, billing records, and investigative requests to assess potential contractual, civil, and criminal exposure under New York and federal law.
17 Nov, 2026

