Matthew Farwell's Federal Charges in the Sandra Birchmore Trial

Practice Area:Criminal Law
Jurisdiction:Federal

Matthew Farwell's federal charges involved killing to prevent communication about possible federal crimes and a separate unborn-child death count.

Under 18 U.S.C. § 1512(a)(1)(C), the federal connection turns on whether information was reasonably likely to reach federal officers. The § 1841 count linked the unborn child's death to the charged § 1512 conduct. A jury found Farwell guilty on both counts on November 10, 2026. Sentencing is scheduled for February 3, 2027.



1. The Two Federal Charges in the Farwell Trial


The Matthew Farwell trial concerning Sandra Birchmore's death involved two counts. The October 28, 2025 superseding indictment added the unborn-child count to the existing witness-killing charge.


Identify What Each Count Required

The charges addressed different deaths and required separate findings:

  • Count One: Killing a witness or victim under § 1512(a)(1)(C).
  • Count Two: Causing an unborn child's death through conduct violating § 1512, under § 1841.

Count One alleged that Farwell killed Birchmore to stop information about possible federal crimes from reaching law enforcement. Count Two addressed the death caused by that conduct during pregnancy.

A state murder charge would depend on state law. These charges required the connections specified in federal statutes. FBI involvement alone did not establish those elements.

Separate Referenced Crimes from Charged Counts

Count One identified three possible federal offenses behind the information Farwell allegedly sought to suppress:

  • Deprivation of rights under color of law, § 242.
  • Coercion and enticement, § 2422(b).
  • Wire fraud, § 1343.

These references did not create three additional counts. They identified the crimes to which the blocked information allegedly related.

A federal criminal defense review distinguishes the charged offense from other conduct described within it.


2. What Connects Witness Killing to Federal Law?


Diagram: Intent to stop communication with law enforcement generally requires a reasonable likelihood of federal communication; remote or hypothetical possibilities are insufficient.
Diagram: Intent to stop communication with law enforcement generally requires a reasonable likelihood of federal communication; remote or hypothetical possibilities are insufficient.

Section 1512(a)(1)(C) requires a particular purpose behind a killing. Prosecutors must connect the act to an intent to prevent information from reaching federal law enforcement or a federal judge.


Examine the Intended Communication

For a completed killing under this provision, the analysis includes:

  • Whether the defendant killed another person.
  • Whether the defendant intended to prevent communication to law enforcement.
  • Whether the information concerned a federal offense or its possible commission.
  • Whether the required federal connection existed.

Fear of embarrassment or job loss alone does not establish the statutory purpose. The evidence must support an intent to stop the relevant communication.

The statute covers communication “by any person.” The intended speaker need not be the person killed.

Apply the Reasonable-Likelihood Standard

In Fowler v. United States (2011), the Supreme Court addressed an intent to prevent communication with law enforcement generally.

In that situation, prosecutors must show a reasonable likelihood that a relevant communication would have reached a federal officer. A remote or purely hypothetical possibility is insufficient.

Federal communication need not have been more likely than not. This rule does not lower the government's burden to prove the charged offense beyond a reasonable doubt.

The defense can examine who might have reported the information and what supported a federal referral. Later federal involvement does not automatically establish that earlier likelihood.


3. Charging Papers and Trial Evidence Answer Different Questions


An indictment states the accusation. Evidence supports or challenges it. A ruling that a charge is adequately stated does not establish guilt.


Understand the Request for More Detail

Farwell requested a bill of particulars, seeking more specific information about the charges. His request addressed the intended communication, possible federal recipient, and federal connection.

The court denied the request on July 21, 2026. That decision concerned whether further detail was necessary to prepare the defense. It did not decide whether the trial evidence would prove guilt.

At a federal court trial, prosecutors must support the elements with evidence. The indictment itself is not evidence.

Match Records to the Disputed Elements

Different records may address different issues:

  • Messages may show an intent to stop disclosure.
  • Calls or reports may identify who knew about the conduct.
  • Employment records may concern an alleged underlying offense.
  • Referral evidence may explain a route to federal investigators.

Evidence of anger does not automatically establish the federal connection. Evidence of that connection does not itself prove who caused the death.

Preserve complete messages and available metadata. Isolated excerpts may leave out facts that change their meaning.


4. The Unborn-Child Count Has Separate Requirements


Section 1841 applies when conduct violating a listed federal law causes death or injury to a child in the womb. Section 1512 is among those listed laws.


Check the Federal Offense and Causation

The death count requires:

  • Conduct violating a law listed in § 1841(b).
  • A child in the womb when the conduct occurred.
  • A causal connection between the conduct and the child's death.

Farwell's superseding indictment tied this count to the alleged § 1512 violation. Pregnancy alone did not supply the federal basis.

Another case needs its own statutory analysis. A pregnant person's death does not automatically establish a § 1841 offense.

Distinguish Intent from the General Rule

The general offense does not require proof that the defendant knew of the pregnancy or separately intended to harm the unborn child.

Section 1841(a)(2)(C) provides a different punishment rule for intentionally killing or attempting to kill the unborn child. Section 1841 bars the death penalty for an offense under that section.


5. Questions about Federal Witness-Killing Charges


Formal witness status and the effect of a verdict raise additional questions for defendants reviewing these charges.


Must the Victim Already Have Spoken to the FBI?

No. Section 1512(a)(1)(C) can apply before a report or subpoena. Prior FBI contact is not required.

Prosecutors must still prove the required intent and federal connection. Calling someone a potential witness does not replace that proof.

Does a Guilty Verdict End the Case?

A verdict does not impose a sentence. Sentencing, permitted post-trial motions, and an appeal follow separate procedures.

A criminal appeals review examines the trial record, rulings, and jury instructions under the applicable standards. It does not automatically produce a second trial.

For a defendant facing similar charges, SJKP LLP can review the indictment and court orders to identify disputed elements and issues requiring a timely response.

19 Nov, 2026


The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
Certain informational content on this website may utilize technology-assisted drafting tools and is subject to attorney review.

Online Consultation
Phone Consultation