1. Which Lease Rights Continue When a Commercial Building Is Sold?
A sale generally does not end an enforceable lease. The new owner's duties depend on the agreement, applicable law, and interests that may take priority over the tenancy.
Identify the Rights That Transfer to the Buyer
New York Real Property Law § 223 gives a new owner certain remedies under an existing lease and allows tenants to enforce covered obligations against a successor landlord. Exceptions include certain covenants about title or possession. Check renewal options, rent increases, repair duties, and exclusive-use clauses. A commercial lease review helps separate continuing duties from earlier claims. Not every past breach becomes the buyer's responsibility.
Check Tenant Statements against the Lease
A tenant estoppel may confirm rent, deposits, amendments, or disputes. Its effect depends on its wording and the parties bound by it.
| Document | What to Verify | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Signed lease | Rent and duties | Continuing obligations |
| Amendment | Renewal rights and concessions | Changed terms |
| Tenant estoppel | Deposits and disputes | Tenant statements |
| Rent ledger | Payments and arrears | Closing adjustments |
Signed lease
- What to VerifyRent and duties
- Why It MattersContinuing obligations
Amendment
- What to VerifyRenewal rights and concessions
- Why It MattersChanged terms
Tenant estoppel
- What to VerifyDeposits and disputes
- Why It MattersTenant statements
Rent ledger
- What to VerifyPayments and arrears
- Why It MattersClosing adjustments
A rent roll does not establish every tenant right. Material differences require clarification.
2. What If the Seller's Security Deposit Records Do Not Match?

A discrepancy may involve missing funds, an accounting error, or an earlier transfer. A closing adjustment does not necessarily satisfy statutory deposit duties.
Compare the Lease, Deposit Ledger, and Bank Records
New York General Obligations Law § 7-103 generally treats rental security deposits as trust funds. A landlord cannot mix them with personal money. When deposited in a bank, written notice must identify the bank, its address, and the amount. Compare each lease with deposit and bank records. Check for increases, authorized deductions, or funds received from a prior owner. If records disagree, identify the difference before closing. An accounting credit alone does not prove a proper transfer.
Address a Missing Deposit before Ownership Changes
Under General Obligations Law § 7-105, a transferring landlord generally must deliver deposits at conveyance or within five days afterward. The landlord must also notify tenants by registered or certified mail of the transfer and recipient's name and address. The statute contains an exception for inconsistent landlord-tenant agreements but does not remove the trust duties under § 7-103. When properly transferred under § 7-105, responsibility for returning the deposit generally passes to the recipient. If funds are missing, the buyer should examine the records and negotiate a documented resolution. A credit or escrow arrangement may not satisfy every statutory duty.
3. How Should Rent and Tenant Obligations Be Handled at Closing?
Rent adjustments and security deposits serve different purposes. The purchase agreement should identify payments owed to each party and rights requiring assignment.
Separate Earlier Rent from Future Payments
A seller may have collected rent for months after closing, while tenants still owe earlier charges. The contract should allocate prepaid rent, unpaid balances, and credits. Earlier claims do not necessarily transfer without an assignment or other legal basis. Advance rent held as security may also fall under GOL § 7-103. A commercial real estate purchase agreement review can clarify these allocations. Closing figures should match the records.
Identify Lender and Local Approval Requirements
A lender may require tenant estoppels, lease assignments, insurance records, or mortgage-related agreements. Loan documents determine delivery conditions. A commercial real estate finance review can identify those requirements. Town or village authorities generally oversee zoning and occupancy rules. The commercial real estate lawyer in NYC article addresses a different municipal system, not Suffolk County approval rules.
4. What If the Seller Cannot Deliver the Required Documents?
Missing records do not automatically justify cancellation. Remedies depend on the seller's duties and whether an enforceable closing condition remains unsatisfied.
Distinguish Required Delivery from Reasonable Efforts
Some agreements require leases, tenant estoppels, or deposit records at closing. Others require only reasonable efforts to obtain them. A tenant's refusal to sign an estoppel may therefore have different consequences. Check whether delivery is a closing condition or whether the seller fulfilled its efforts obligation.
Follow the Contract's Notice and Remedy Provisions
Depending on the agreement, a buyer may:
- Request missing records.
- Negotiate a written extension.
- Agree to a revised closing adjustment.
- Exercise a contractual remedy for nonperformance.
New York General Obligations Law § 5-703 generally requires a real property sale contract to be written and signed by the party to be charged, subject to exceptions. An extension should satisfy the agreement's modification rules. Informal discussions may not preserve a deadline.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
How Much Does a Commercial Real Estate Attorney Charge on Long Island?
Fees may be fixed or hourly. Multiple tenants, disputed records, and financing can increase the work. Ask whether the engagement covers negotiations, deposit verification, lender requirements, and closing. Additional disputes may cost extra.
Can One Attorney Represent Both the Buyer and Seller in New York?
Joint representation may be possible under New York Rule of Professional Conduct 1.7. The attorney must reasonably believe competent and diligent representation is possible, and the conflict must be legally consentable. Each affected client must give informed consent confirmed in writing. Some conflicts cannot be waived. Separate attorneys may be needed when the parties dispute financial adjustments or lease obligations.
6. Review a Commercial Property Purchase with SJKP LLP
SJKP LLP's attorneys can review leases, deposit discrepancies, rent allocations, and closing requirements for Suffolk County commercial purchases. The review can identify unresolved obligations and contractual options before ownership changes.
18 Nov, 2026

