1. Property Disputes Require a Defined Legal Claim
A failed closing, conflicting deed, and encroachment require different proof. The claim must match the right in dispute.
Breach of a Purchase Agreement
A buyer facing a failed sale should check the signed contract, contingencies, deadlines, and cancellation notices. California Civil Code § 1624(a)(3) generally requires a written agreement or memorandum signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought, subject to recognized exceptions. The seller may have grounds to refuse closing if the buyer missed a condition. A buyer seeking a transfer order must also show readiness to perform. Check for contractual mediation, arbitration, or presuit notice requirements. Separate breach of contract litigation principles address material breach and recoverable loss.
Ownership, Possession, and Boundary Claims
Competing deeds raise title questions. An encroaching fence may support trespass. Driveway use may involve an easement rather than ownership. Compare the legal description, claimed interest, and actual use. A survey establishes measurements, not a final ruling on ownership.
2. Evidence Review Must Connect Records to the Claim

Match records to disputed facts. An online property summary rarely establishes the entire claim.
Deeds, Recorded Interests, and Surveys
San Francisco's Assessor-Recorder maintains recorded deeds, liens, and maps. Obtain the instruments and compare grantors, dates, legal descriptions, and easements. A parcel number can help locate records, but it does not replace the deed's legal description. A deed's recording does not establish that every transfer was valid. Surveys locate boundaries and improvements. Competing ownership claims may require older deeds or testimony.
Notices, Escrow Records, and Permit History
Preserve signed agreements, escrow instructions, payment records, and original messages. Document notice delivery when a contingency or cancellation deadline is disputed. San Francisco Department of Building Inspection records may show permits and inspection history, but do not establish ownership. Transaction questions outside an existing lawsuit fall within broader California real estate lawyer services.
3. Remedies Depend on the Right the Plaintiff Can Prove
Damages, transfer orders, and title judgments require different legal showings.
Damages and Specific Performance
Damages require a legally recoverable loss caused by breach. Specific performance asks the court to enforce the transfer. California Civil Code § 3387 presumes money is inadequate compensation for breach of an agreement to transfer real property. That presumption is conclusive for a single-family dwelling the claimant intends to occupy, but only on the adequacy of damages. Contract enforceability, readiness to perform, and equitable defenses remain relevant.
Quiet Title and Lis Pendens
A quiet title action resolves competing property claims. Under Code of Civil Procedure § 761.020, a verified complaint must identify the property, claimed title, adverse interests, and determination date. Section 762.060(b) requires naming recorded, known, or reasonably apparent adverse claimants. Section 761.010(b) requires recording a lis pendens immediately upon filing. Other cases may qualify under § 405.20 if they assert a real property claim, not merely monetary damages. Under § 405.32, a court must expunge a challenged notice if the claimant cannot establish probable validity.
Injunctions against Ongoing Interference
Code of Civil Procedure § 527 permits qualifying requests for temporary relief against active encroachment. An injunction does not itself settle title. More detailed boundary dispute claims address trespass, easements, and encroachments.
4. Filing Location and Procedural Deadlines Need Separate Review
Property title claims and contract claims may follow different venue rules.
Superior Court Venue, E-Filing, and Department 501
Code of Civil Procedure § 392 generally places actions determining an interest in land in the county where it lies. San Francisco Superior Court's Civil Clerk's Office is at 400 McAllister Street, Room 103. Local Rule 2.11 generally requires electronic filing in covered civil cases, with exceptions. Department 501 handles law-and-motion matters involving property ownership, possession, acquisition, or damage, except construction defects. Non-eviction property discovery motions first go to Departments 301 or 302, then to 501 if unresolved. Department 501 requires courtesy copies.
Limitation Periods and Case Management
Code of Civil Procedure § 337 generally gives four years for written contract claims, while § 339 generally gives two years for nonwritten contract claims. Section 338(b) provides three years for trespass or injury to real property, but continuing and permanent intrusions can have different accrual rules. Do not apply these periods automatically to quiet title or possession claims. California Rule of Court 3.725 requires filing and service of Form CM-110 at least 15 calendar days before the case management conference. Rule 3.724 generally also requires the parties to meet and confer at least 30 calendar days before the initial conference. Summons service has separate deadlines.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
Does an Unpermitted Structure Automatically Establish Civil Liability?
No. A permit violation may provide evidence but does not prove trespass, breach, or ownership. A private claimant still needs a legally recognized cause of action and proof supporting the requested remedy. Building enforcement and private title litigation address different issues.
Can a Nonresident Owner File the Dispute in Federal Court?
Nonresidence alone does not create federal jurisdiction. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1332, diversity jurisdiction generally requires complete diversity of citizenship and an amount in controversy exceeding $75,000. A federal question may provide another basis. Ordinary title and purchase disputes usually arise under state law.
13 Nov, 2026

