The willfulness question
FBAR penalties fall into two broad categories. Non-willful penalties apply to failures that were not intentional, and the Supreme Court has held that they are counted per report rather than per account, which limits exposure for people with many accounts. Willful penalties are much larger and can be measured against account balances. Courts have generally treated reckless disregard and willful blindness as willful for civil purposes, so not knowing is not always a defense if warning signs were ignored, such as the foreign account question on a tax return. In serious cases, deliberate concealment can lead to criminal charges, often alongside tax evasion or false return charges.
How a penalty case moves
FBAR penalties usually arise in an IRS examination. The examiner gathers account records, may interview you, and then proposes a penalty, often applying internal mitigation guidelines that consider account balances and your history. You can generally ask the IRS Independent Office of Appeals to review a proposed penalty before it is assessed. Because FBAR penalties are not income taxes, an unpaid assessed penalty is generally pursued through a federal lawsuit where you can contest it, although offsets against federal payments can also occur. The IRS may also ask you to extend the time it has to assess, a request that should be considered with advice rather than signed by reflex.
What we look at first
Bring every IRS letter, the foreign account statements, your tax returns for the years involved, and anything showing how the accounts were opened and who advised you. We look at how much the IRS already knows, whether income from the accounts was reported, and what the record shows about your knowledge at the time, including any preparer questionnaires you answered. That analysis drives the strategy, whether it is a reasonable-cause defense, an argument about the number of violations, or an appeal. If the facts suggest criminal exposure, the approach to interviews and document production changes, and we address that at the start.






