When activity becomes taxable presence
Without a treaty, a foreign corporation is generally taxed in the United States on income effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business, a threshold that fairly modest activity can meet. A tax treaty usually raises that threshold: business profits are taxed only if they are attributable to a permanent establishment, such as a fixed place of business or a dependent agent who habitually concludes contracts for the company. Preparatory or auxiliary activities, like storage or market research, are often excluded, although treaty language varies. Remote employees, long-running project sites, and sales staff with real authority are common sources of permanent establishment tax exposure. State taxes are a separate question, because states generally apply their own nexus rules and are not bound by income tax treaties in the same way.
Filings that protect the company
A foreign corporation with U.S. business activity, or one relying on a treaty to shield that activity, typically files the U.S. corporate return for foreign corporations, and treaty-based positions generally have to be disclosed. A protective return can matter when the position is uncertain, because deductions and credits may be denied if a required return is not filed on time. If a permanent establishment exists, the profits attributable to it are taxed, and a branch profits tax may apply on top, subject to treaty reduction. Payroll, withholding, and state registration questions often come along with the corporate tax issue. Records showing what U.S. staff actually do, where contracts are signed, and who approves them are central evidence.
Reviewing your structure
We start with a factual map: who works in the United States and for how long, what authority they hold, where contracts are negotiated and executed, and whether any premises are at the company's disposal. We read the applicable treaty and compare that map against its permanent establishment article. Options may include adjusting roles and contracting processes, forming a U.S. subsidiary with proper intercompany agreements, or filing protectively while the analysis continues. If the IRS has already raised the issue, we also look at prior years and at whether the treaty's mutual agreement procedure may be needed to avoid double taxation. Bring employment contracts, intercompany agreements, and recent tax filings in both countries.






