Business Tax Lawyer in San Francisco Reviews IRS Letter 1153

Practice Area:Others
Jurisdiction:California


Business tax lawyers in San Francisco review IRS Letter 1153 under IRC § 6672 to assess responsibility and willful failure to remit withheld taxes.

A company officer may face a proposed personal penalty even when another employee processed payroll. Bank permissions, deposit records, and payment instructions can show who controlled funds and when the shortfall became known. A protest must identify disputed tax periods and meet the notice's filing deadline.



1. Letter 1153 Gives Notice of a Proposed Personal Penalty


The IRS uses Letter 1153 and Form 2751 to propose a Trust Fund Recovery Penalty (TFRP) under IRC § 6672. The company's unpaid taxes and the individual's proposed liability require separate review. Unlike a tax bill, this notice normally comes before assessment.


Read Form 2751 before Agreeing

Form 2751 lists amounts by tax period. Check whether the officer had payment authority in each disputed quarter. Note when any job or bank authorization began or ended.

Signing it indicates agreement, but IRS procedures allow a timely protest during the original response period even after signing.

Recalculate the Trust Fund Amount

For payroll taxes, the TFRP generally covers withheld federal income tax and the employee share of Social Security and Medicare taxes, not the employer's share or separate deposit penalties.

Compare Forms 941, payroll reports, deposits, and IRS transcripts for missing credits or corrected returns. Payroll tax compliance addresses the company's duties, not this proposed individual penalty.


2. The Letter 1153 Response Period Controls the Appeal


A written protest generally must be filed within 60 days after the IRS mails or personally delivers Letter 1153. The period is 75 days if the letter is addressed outside the United States. These are federal rules, regardless of where the business operates.


Check the Date and Preserve Proof of Filing

Count from mailing or personal delivery, not when the officer reads the letter. Under IRC § 7503, a weekend or legal-holiday deadline generally moves to the next business day.

Address the protest to the IRS employee named in Letter 1153. Keep the submission and mailing evidence. Under IRS procedures, timely mailing can preserve the protest, so retain a reliable postmark or certified-mail record. An informal discussion does not extend the deadline.

Select the Correct Written Protest

A small case request may be available for proposed amounts of $25,000 or less. A formal written protest is required if any listed period or the sum of the listed periods exceeds $25,000.

Identify the notice, disputed quarters, facts, applicable law, and request for an Appeals conference. A formal protest requires a declaration under penalties of perjury. Unlike other federal tax disputes, Letter 1153 has its own deadline.


3. The Evidence Must Address Control and Willfulness Separately


Diagram: Two parallel evidentiary tracks for IRC 6672 liability: assessing responsibility and evaluating willfulness.
Diagram: Two parallel evidentiary tracks for IRC 6672 liability: assessing responsibility and evaluating willfulness.

IRC § 6672 requires both responsibility for the trust fund taxes and willful failure to collect or pay them. Neither a job title nor a check-signing privilege resolves both questions.


Distinguish Bank Access from Payment Authority

The IRS considers who could approve deposits, choose creditors, or change spending priorities. Actual instructions may differ from corporate titles.

An employee who only followed a supervisor's payment decisions may lack control. Outsourcing payroll does not necessarily relieve an owner who retained authority. Compare job duties with approvals and bank records.

Build a Timeline of Knowledge and Payments

Willfulness may exist when a responsible person knows withheld taxes remain unpaid and chooses to pay other creditors. Reckless disregard of clear warnings can also qualify. The IRS need not prove an intent to defraud.

Record when warnings arrived, what money was available, and who directed payments. Earlier delinquencies may require separate analysis when control changed. See personal payroll tax liability for the underlying rules.


4. The Protest Should Answer Specific IRS Findings


A protest should challenge specific findings or quarters. The revenue officer reviews it first, with unresolved issues referred to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals. The same explanation may not fit every period when an officer's authority changed.


Match Each Disputed Finding to Records

Disputed IssueEvidence to ComparePurpose
Financial controlBank authority, approval emailsIdentify who chose creditors
Knowledge of nonpaymentIRS letters, accountant warningsEstablish when notice arose
Penalty amountForms 941, deposits, transcriptsCheck balances and credits

Financial control

  • Evidence to CompareBank authority, approval emails
  • PurposeIdentify who chose creditors

Knowledge of nonpayment

  • Evidence to CompareIRS letters, accountant warnings
  • PurposeEstablish when notice arose

Penalty amount

  • Evidence to CompareForms 941, deposits, transcripts
  • PurposeCheck balances and credits

Explain how each record supports the disputed period or finding. Unsorted attachments rarely answer the IRS's specific allegations.

Review Earlier Interviews and Separate Tax Agencies

Review the IRS's Form 4180 interview against actual duties. Address inaccurate statements with dates and records.

Missing the deadline may lead to assessment. A later refund claim follows a different process. California and city tax notices have separate rules, as the San Francisco business tax overview explains.


5. Frequently Asked Questions


Can More Than One Officer Receive Letter 1153?

Yes. Multiple people may each be responsible, but their conduct is assessed separately. The IRS cannot collect the same underlying trust fund tax twice.

Must an Officer Pay Before Challenging Letter 1153?

No. A preassessment administrative protest requires no advance payment. After assessment, a refund claim follows different requirements.


16 Nov, 2026


The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
Certain informational content on this website may utilize technology-assisted drafting tools and is subject to attorney review.

Online Consultation
Phone Consultation