What Does a Gift Tax Attorney in Brooklyn Check after an IRS Notice?

Practice Area:Estate Planning
Jurisdiction:New York

A gift tax attorney in Brooklyn checks whether Form 709 adequately disclosed a gift and whether IRC § 6501 permits further IRS assessment.

An IRS inquiry may concern a family transfer made years earlier. A valuation dispute does not automatically mean additional tax is owed. The donor must identify the disputed transaction and determine whether the notice requests evidence or starts a formal challenge period.



1. Identify the Gift and the IRS Notice


An IRS letter may question the reported transfer, its value, or the original disclosure. The specific issue determines which records and deadlines matter.


Connect the Inquiry to a Specific Transfer

Read the notice number, tax year, mailing date, and requested action. Compare these with Form 709 and the transfer documents. Preserve the notice and prior responses. A records request does not establish a tax deficiency. If several gifts appear on the return, identify which transfer the IRS is examining.

Distinguish Federal Gift Tax from State Estate Tax

The IRS administers federal gift tax, which generally falls on the donor. New York imposes no separate gift tax. Under New York Tax Law § 954(a)(3), certain taxable gifts made within three years before death may increase the New York gross estate, subject to statutory exceptions. This does not determine federal gift-tax liability. Related estate planning tax rules explain the distinction.


2. Resolve Discrepancies in the Reported Gift


A filed return does not establish that the IRS accepted the transfer date, ownership interest, or valuation. The donor needs evidence of what was transferred.


Establish When Ownership Actually Changed

A signed agreement does not always establish when a gift became complete. Examine when the recipient obtained ownership rights and whether the donor retained control.

Review records connected to the disputed gift:

  • Form 709 and supporting schedules.
  • Deeds, share registers, LLC agreements, or trust instruments.
  • Payment records showing consideration received.
  • Gift-date appraisals and financial statements.

The gift completion date generally determines when the IRS measures fair market value. For 2026, the annual exclusion is generally $19,000 per recipient for qualifying gifts, and the basic exclusion is $15 million. Earlier transfers follow their applicable year's rules.

Test Valuation and Adequate Disclosure

For business interests, compare appraisal assumptions with voting rights, ownership restrictions, and financial records. A later sale does not automatically establish gift-date value. IRC § 6501(a) generally provides a three-year assessment period, with returns filed early treated as filed on their due date. Under § 6501(c)(9), an inadequately disclosed gift may remain open to assessment. Treas. Reg. § 301.6501(c)-1(f) requires sufficient disclosure of the transfer, including the recipient, consideration, and valuation basis. The issue is what the original return revealed, not merely whether Form 709 was filed. The gift tax reporting page addresses general filing obligations.


3. Respond to the IRS Finding before the Deadline


Diagram: A vertical timeline showing an IRS records request, a possible valuation adjustment, and a deficiency notice with a Tax Court deadline.
Diagram: A vertical timeline showing an IRS records request, a possible valuation adjustment, and a deficiency notice with a Tax Court deadline.

An examination may progress from a records request to a proposed adjustment and statutory deficiency notice. Each stage offers different response options.

IRS StageDecision to Make
Examination requestWhich records answer the IRS questions?
Proposed adjustmentWhich valuation findings can be challenged?
Statutory deficiency noticeWhen must a Tax Court petition be filed?
Assessed balanceWhich liability or collection remedies remain?

Examination request

  • Decision to MakeWhich records answer the IRS questions?

Proposed adjustment

  • Decision to MakeWhich valuation findings can be challenged?

Statutory deficiency notice

  • Decision to MakeWhen must a Tax Court petition be filed?

Assessed balance

  • Decision to MakeWhich liability or collection remedies remain?

Challenge the Basis of a Proposed Adjustment

Compare the IRS calculation with the original appraisal. For closely held shares, examine comparable companies, financial projections, and ownership discounts. Submit evidence addressing disputed findings and retain proof of delivery. Depending on the examination stage, review by the IRS Independent Office of Appeals may be available. The IRS audit defense page explains broader examination procedures.

Preserve the Tax Court Petition Deadline

Under IRC § 6213(a), a statutory notice of deficiency generally allows 90 days after mailing to petition the U.S. Tax Court, or 150 days when addressed to a person outside the United States. If the deadline falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or District of Columbia legal holiday, statutory extension rules apply. The last filing date specified in the notice also has legal significance. A timely petition generally permits review before payment. IRS discussions or reconsideration requests do not automatically extend the deadline.


4. Correct Filing Errors without Losing Procedural Rights


An omitted transfer may require correction, but filing additional information does not replace a response to a pending IRS notice.


Determine What a Corrected Form 709 Can Address

An unreported gift may require Form 709 for the original transfer year. To amend a filed return, IRS instructions generally require another Form 709 marked as amended, an explanation, supporting records, and a copy of the original. During an examination, provide corrections to the examining office. A later disclosure does not automatically establish that the original return met the adequate disclosure standard or suspend a Tax Court deadline.

Separate an Assessed Debt from a Valuation Dispute

After assessment, compare the IRS balance with prior payments, penalties, and notices. Determine whether the dispute concerns liability or collection. A taxpayer who previously had an opportunity to contest the liability may face restrictions on raising it during a collection hearing. The IRS tax attorney in NYC article addresses collection notices and bank levies rather than proposed gift-tax deficiencies.


5. Frequently Asked Questions


Does Adding an Adult Child to a House Deed Create a Taxable Gift?

Possibly. Adding a child may constitute a completed gift if the child receives a property interest without equivalent consideration. The deed, mortgage obligations, ownership form, and retained rights affect the result. Adding a name does not necessarily transfer half the property's value or create immediate tax liability.

Can Spouses Elect Gift Splitting After an IRS Notice?

An examination request alone does not prohibit gift splitting. Under IRC § 2513, eligible spouses may consent to treating qualifying gifts to third parties as made one-half by each spouse. Consent generally must be made by April 15 following the gift year, subject to applicable filing extensions and special timing rules. Under § 2513(b), consent cannot be made after the IRS sends a statutory gift-tax deficiency notice for that year to either spouse. Earlier filings may also affect eligibility.



6. Review an IRS Gift Tax Notice with SJKP LLP


SJKP LLP's attorneys can review IRS correspondence, Form 709, transfer agreements, and valuation records to assess disputed findings and available procedures. The review may clarify whether disclosure, valuation, assessment, or a filing deadline remains at issue.


16 Nov, 2026


The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
Certain informational content on this website may utilize technology-assisted drafting tools and is subject to attorney review.

Online Consultation
Phone Consultation