1. Contract Payment Defenses and Lien Rights Are Separate
Withholding payment from a direct contractor concerns the owner's contract. A mechanics lien is a statutory claim against the improved property. A subcontractor may assert lien rights without having a direct contract with the owner. These rules concern private construction projects. Public and federal projects have different security procedures.
Identify Who Is Making the Demand
An invoice, a formal statutory payment claim, and a recorded mechanics lien are not interchangeable. An invoice requests contract payment. A claim under Civil Code § 8850 invokes a statutory dispute procedure, while a lien asserts a property claim. Identify the sender and document type before responding.
Trace Payments Beyond the Direct Contractor
A bank record showing payment to the general contractor does not establish that subcontractors and suppliers received their shares. Match each payee to the work performed, payments made, and signed releases. The construction contract also establishes who may authorize changes or submit payment demands.
2. Withheld Payments Must Match a Genuine Dispute
The amount an owner may withhold depends on why the money remains unpaid. Progress payments, disputed charges, and contractual retention follow different rules.
Calculate the Undisputed Progress Payment
Civil Code § 8800 generally requires payment of an undisputed progress amount within 30 days after a compliant demand, unless the owner and direct contractor agree otherwise in writing. Compare completed work with the payment schedule and approved credits. A disagreement over one item does not justify withholding unrelated amounts due.
Limit a Good-Faith Withholding
Under § 8800(b), a good-faith dispute permits withholding no more than 150% of the disputed progress-payment amount. Record the defective item, estimated correction cost, and basis for the figure. Section 8800(c) imposes a 2% monthly penalty on sums wrongfully withheld. It also allows prevailing-party costs and reasonable attorney's fees in a collection action.
Keep Retention Separate from Defect Deductions
For qualifying private-work contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2026, Civil Code § 8811 generally caps retention at 5% of each payment and the contract price.
The cap excludes non-mixed-use residential projects of four stories or fewer and includes a narrow subcontractor bond exception. Ordinary defect deductions are not automatically retention.
Recognize a Formal 2026 Payment Claim
For covered contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2026, Civil Code § 8850 applies to qualifying claims sent by registered or certified mail with return receipt requested.
The owner generally has 30 days to identify disputed and undisputed portions in writing and 60 days after that response to pay the undisputed portion. A written extension agreement may apply. Non-mixed-use residential projects of four stories or fewer are excluded.
Failure to respond generally results in a deemed denial, not approval. Further conference and mediation procedures may apply, and statutory interest may accrue.
3. Extra Charges and Defect Credits Need Different Proof
An extra-work demand asks whether the owner approved additional work. A defect credit concerns performance of the original scope. Merging the two can obscure both claims.
Verify Change-Order Approval
Compare the original scope and drawings with the extra-work request, price adjustment, and signer's authority.
Business and Professions Code § 7159 generally requires written, signed change orders before extra work begins under covered home improvement contracts. Missing signatures raise compliance concerns but may not resolve every possible payment theory.
Support the Cost of Correction
Keep dated photographs, inspection findings, repair proposals, and records of contractor responses. Distinguish work needed to correct an original defect from an upgrade requested later. Avoid deducting the same repair charge twice.
Claims involving qualifying new residential construction may require separate prelitigation procedures. See construction defect litigation for the related legal issues.
4. Lien Notices and Releases Require Claimant-Specific Review

An owner should evaluate lien paperwork by claimant, not by the total amount paid to the general contractor. Notice compliance, actual work value, waivers, and filing deadlines can each affect the claim.
Check Preliminary Notices and Signed Waivers
Civil Code § 8200 generally requires preliminary notice from subcontractors and suppliers, subject to exceptions. Sections 8132–8138 prescribe conditional and unconditional waiver forms.
A release from the direct contractor does not release an unpaid supplier. A conditional waiver generally takes effect only after the claimant receives the specified payment.
Test the Lien Amount and Enforcement Deadline
Under Civil Code § 8430, a lien is generally limited to the lesser of the claimant's reasonable work value and the agreed price, subject to statutory qualifications. Check the claimed amount against work records and payment credits.
Section 8460 generally requires lien enforcement within 90 days after recording, subject to a qualifying recorded credit extension. The Orange County construction guide addresses preliminary notices and recording requirements in more detail.
Consider a Release Bond without Assuming Payment
Civil Code § 8424 permits an eligible party to record a lien release bond, generally for 125% of the claimed lien amount, issued by an admitted surety insurer.
Recording the bond releases the property from the lien, but the claimant may pursue the bond. It does not establish that the disputed debt was paid. A lien release bond and a contractor's payment bond serve different purposes.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
How Much Does a Construction Lawyer Cost in California?
Fees depend on whether the work involves reviewing payment demands and lien records or extends to negotiation, arbitration, or litigation. Ask which tasks, filing fees, expert expenses, and court appearances the proposed arrangement covers.
Can an Owner Sue a Construction Company in California?
An owner may pursue an available contract or construction claim in the appropriate court, subject to applicable deadlines and any enforceable arbitration agreement.
A Contractors State License Board (CSLB) complaint addresses licensing or workmanship issues but does not replace a damages lawsuit or discharge a lien.
20 Nov, 2026

