1. The Charging Document Determines the Filing Court

Compare the charging document, judgment date, and trial court docket before choosing a form. The offense listed in the final judgment may not reveal which appellate route applies.
Felony Notices Go to the Central Justice Center
File form CR-120 in the Criminal Department of the Central Justice Center, 700 Civic Center Drive West, Santa Ana, CA 92701. Under California Rule of Court 8.308, a defendant generally has 60 days after judgment or the appealable order. The Fourth District Court of Appeal, Division Three, hears the appeal but does not receive the initial notice.
Rule 8.304(a) defines a felony case by an information or indictment charging a felony, or a felony complaint certified under Penal Code § 859a. That classification may persist after conviction of a lesser offense or reduction under § 17(b).
Misdemeanor and Infraction Appeals Follow Separate Filing Rules
For a misdemeanor case outside the felony definition, file form CR-132 with the Criminal Department where the case was heard. For an infraction, submit form CR-142 to the original court's Traffic Division. Rules 8.853 and 8.902 generally allow 30 days after judgment or the appealable order. The Superior Court Appellate Division hears both types of appeals. Orange County's L-0986 packet provides misdemeanor appeal forms.
Federal Notices Are Filed in District Court
For a federal criminal judgment, Rule 4(b) of the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure generally gives the defendant 14 days to file in the U.S. district court, not the Ninth Circuit. The Central District's Santa Ana courthouse is at 411 West Fourth Street. Check the assigned docket and any motions affecting the deadline before filing.
2. Only Appealable Decisions Qualify for Direct Review
A defendant cannot appeal every unfavorable trial ruling immediately. Penal Code § 1237 generally allows an appeal from a final felony judgment or a qualifying order made after judgment. The challenged decision determines the available issues.
Trial Rulings May Be Reviewed after Judgment
Errors in jury instructions or evidentiary decisions can be raised in an appeal from the final judgment when the governing rules permit. Postjudgment orders must affect substantial rights to qualify under § 1237(b). A misdemeanor appeal follows Penal Code § 1466 and Rule 8.852. See criminal appeals for the distinction between reviewable errors and a new trial.
Pleas Can Require a Certificate of Probable Cause
A felony defendant attacking the validity of a guilty or no-contest plea generally must file a written statement seeking a certificate under Penal Code § 1237.5 with the notice of appeal. Rule 8.304(b) gives the trial court 20 days after the statement is filed to grant or deny it.
A qualifying challenge to denial of a Penal Code § 1538.5 suppression motion, or a postplea sentencing issue that does not attack plea validity, generally needs no certificate. A plea agreement may impose additional limits.
3. The Record Must Support the Claimed Error
An appellate court usually evaluates what happened below, not new witness testimony. Rule 8.320 specifies the normal felony record, but the relevant exhibits and transcripts must correspond to each proposed issue.
Match Rulings to Motions and Transcripts
For a suppression issue, check the motion, hearing transcript, and order. For a jury instruction challenge, identify the instruction and objection. For sentencing, compare the oral ruling with the judgment. Rule 8.324 permits requests for certain material outside the normal record. See California criminal appeals record review for a fuller discussion of preserved issues.
Misdemeanor Appeals Have a Second Filing Deadline
Under Rule 8.864, an appellant generally must elect whether to use a record of the oral proceedings within 20 days after filing the notice. Form CR-134 can specify a transcript, an available authorized recording, or a statement on appeal.
When the appellant timely requests appointed appellate counsel, the election is due on the later of that 20-day period or 10 days after appointment or denial. Without an adequate oral record, disputed testimony or rulings may be difficult to review.
4. Other Remedies May Be Needed Beyond an Appeal
A direct appeal ordinarily proceeds on the existing record. A newly discovered fact or an error not reflected in the transcript may call for a distinct motion or petition, with its own eligibility rules.
New-Trial Motions Usually Come before Judgment
Penal Code § 1181 authorizes new-trial motions on specified grounds, including some legal errors and newly discovered evidence. Section 1182 generally requires the motion to be made and decided before judgment. A denial may be reviewed on an appeal from the final judgment under § 1237(a).
State Habeas and Vacatur Motions Serve Different Purposes
A state habeas petition may address qualifying constitutional violations supported by facts outside the appeal record. Penal Code § 1473.7 allows certain people no longer in criminal custody to seek to vacate a conviction or sentence on specified grounds, including prejudicial immigration-related error. A California appellate defense review can distinguish errors visible in the record from claims requiring outside evidence. Neither procedure automatically revives an expired appeal.
Federal Section 2255 Motions Have a Different Deadline
A person in federal custody under sentence may file a section 2255 motion in the sentencing court. Section 2255(f) usually provides one year from the applicable statutory trigger, rather than the 14-day direct appeal window.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
How Much Does a Criminal Appeals Lawyer Cost?
Fees depend on transcript length, briefing complexity, and whether the agreement covers record preparation or separate post-conviction work. Ask what the quoted fee includes and which expenses are billed separately.
What Are the Chances of Winning a Criminal Appeal?
The court looks for reviewable error under the applicable standard, including whether the defendant preserved the issue and whether relief is warranted. A successful appeal may lead to resentencing, a new hearing, or retrial rather than acquittal.
17 Nov, 2026

