1. What Is the Current Status of the USCIS Deference Proposal?
As of November 18, 2026, Federal Register document 2026-20941 remains a proposed rule. DHS published it on October 14, with comments due November 13. That comment deadline was not an effective date.
These are federal immigration rules that apply nationwide.
The Proposed Change to Prior Approval Deference
DHS proposes deleting 8 CFR § 214.1(c)(5). This provision requires USCIS to respect earlier eligibility findings involving the same parties and underlying facts, subject to exceptions.
If finalized as proposed, officers could still consider earlier approvals. They would no longer have to begin from a position of deference.
Exceptions under the Current Rule
USCIS may already decline to defer when there is:
- A material error in the earlier approval.
- A material change in circumstances or eligibility requirements.
- New, material information that adversely affects eligibility.
“Material” means significant to the eligibility decision. The same job title does not establish that the actual work remains unchanged.
2. Is the Previous H-1B Approval Notice Enough?
An I-797 notice records an earlier approval. It does not establish current eligibility or show the full evidence USCIS reviewed.
For an H-1B extension, the employer generally files Form I-129. The beneficiary provides relevant personal and employment records.
Review the Earlier Filing
Ask the employer or its attorney for available copies of:
- The approved I-129 and employer support letter.
- The certified Labor Condition Application, or LCA.
- The job description and qualification evidence.
- Any earlier Request for Evidence and response.
Compare the approved duties, worksite, employer, and degree requirements with the proposed extension. A copied support letter may describe work the employee no longer performs.
Document Maintenance of Status Separately
Under 8 CFR § 214.1(c)(6), a request to extend stay requires supporting evidence of maintaining the previously granted status. Relevant records may include pay statements, W-2 forms, and other employment documents.
Review the current I-94 alongside approval notices when checking authorized stay. A visa stamp’s expiration date does not, by itself, determine when that stay ends.
3. Which I-129 Extension Evidence Needs Updating?

Some records document completed events, such as earning a degree. Others must reflect current employment or the requested extension period.
| Evidence | What to check |
|---|---|
| Prior approval and petition | Employer, beneficiary, classification, and approved period. |
| Job description | Current duties and changes in responsibility. |
| Degree and evaluation | Accuracy and connection to the offered work. |
| Employment records | Continued employment and availability of the position. |
| LCA | Coverage of the requested period, worksite, and employment terms. |
| Status records | Relevant employment history since the earlier filing. |
Prior approval and petition
- What to checkEmployer, beneficiary, classification, and approved period.
Job description
- What to checkCurrent duties and changes in responsibility.
Degree and evaluation
- What to checkAccuracy and connection to the offered work.
Employment records
- What to checkContinued employment and availability of the position.
LCA
- What to checkCoverage of the requested period, worksite, and employment terms.
Status records
- What to checkRelevant employment history since the earlier filing.
Retain Useful Academic Records
The proposal does not require a new diploma or credential evaluation for each extension. Check whether the existing evidence remains accurate and sufficient.
Under 8 CFR § 214.2(h)(4), the job and worker must qualify separately. The position must require a directly related specialized degree or its equivalent. A worker’s advanced degree alone cannot establish that requirement.
Refresh Evidence of the Offered Position
The employer must establish a genuine specialty occupation position available at the requested start date. Current letters, project records, or relevant contracts may support that showing.
These are examples, not mandatory documents for every case. The regulations do not require proof of specific daily assignments throughout the requested period.
Related immigration compliance records address wage and LCA obligations. They should remain consistent with the extension’s employment terms.
4. Resolve Changes before Filing an Unchanged Extension
Describe the facts that exist now. Do not preserve an outdated description simply to make the extension resemble the earlier petition.
Report Differences to the Employer
Flag changes involving:
- Substantially different duties or responsibilities.
- A new worksite or remote work location.
- A different legal employing entity.
- Client assignments that change the actual work.
- Employment interruptions or unexplained payroll gaps.
Not every change requires an amended petition. Review whether it materially affects the approved employment or creates another filing obligation. Record what changed and when.
Address the Specific Question in an RFE
A Request for Evidence does not mean the proposed removal is effective. It identifies an issue USCIS considers unresolved.
A USCIS RFE response should address that issue with relevant records and, where appropriate, explain why current deference applies.
SJKP LLP can review differences between the approved record and proposed extension when they raise eligibility or filing questions.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
The proposal also raises questions about existing approvals and pending extensions.
No. The proposed deletion concerns how USCIS weighs earlier eligibility findings. It would not, by itself, revoke existing approvals. Revocation follows separate rules and procedures.
An early filing date alone would not settle which rules govern a pending case. Any final rule would need review for its effective date and treatment of pending filings.
Do not assume either retroactive application or protection based solely on the filing date.
18 Nov, 2026

