1. Has the Seller Breached the Purchase Agreement?
The first question is what the seller agreed to deliver. A delayed transaction is different from a refusal to honor a binding obligation.
Match the Promise to the Problem
A seller may refuse to sign a deed, leave a mortgage unpaid, or fail to deliver vacant possession. The agreement determines whether that condition violates the sale. A title report or lease helps establish the facts. If the contract promises insurable title, compare the proposed title policy and its exceptions with that promise.
| Seller's Problem | Evidence to Check | Contract Question |
|---|---|---|
| Seller refuses to convey | Signed agreement and messages | Has the seller clearly refused to perform? |
| Mortgage remains on title | Title report and payoff records | Must the seller discharge it? |
| An occupant remains | Possession clause and lease | Was vacant possession promised? |
| Closing is postponed | Contract and written notices | Was the date legally binding? |
Seller refuses to convey
- Evidence to CheckSigned agreement and messages
- Contract QuestionHas the seller clearly refused to perform?
Mortgage remains on title
- Evidence to CheckTitle report and payoff records
- Contract QuestionMust the seller discharge it?
An occupant remains
- Evidence to CheckPossession clause and lease
- Contract QuestionWas vacant possession promised?
Closing is postponed
- Evidence to CheckContract and written notices
- Contract QuestionWas the date legally binding?
Check the amendment clause before relying on a verbal promise or an extension.
Check the Seller's Cure Rights and Exceptions
Contracts may allow time to clear a title defect or limit remedies when the seller cannot remove it despite required efforts. Read the cure and default clauses together. A missing mortgage satisfaction does not prove the debt remains unpaid. Check for a release and who must record it. General duties appear under New York real estate law.
2. Can the Buyer Recover the Contract Deposit?
A failed closing does not automatically return the down payment. Escrow terms and each party's performance matter.
Read the Deposit and Escrow Terms
Check who holds the funds and what permits release. A disputed deposit may remain in escrow until agreement or a court decision, depending on the escrow terms.
Seller default may support a refund. A contract might make that refund the exclusive remedy for certain title failures, but not for willful refusal to sell. The exact clause matters. A seller cannot automatically keep the deposit by declaring buyer default if the seller could not perform on the legally required date.
Establish Who Was Able to Close
A buyer claiming seller default often must show readiness, willingness, and ability to close. A mortgage commitment, proof of funds, and closing messages can help. The evidence should relate to the date on which performance was required. Conditional approval may be insufficient. Courts also examine whether the seller could deliver the promised title on time. An unequivocal refusal to sell may excuse the buyer's actual tender in some circumstances.
Compare notices and performance with the real estate transfer process before determining the source of the dispute.
3. When Does a Missed Closing Date Become Default?
A scheduled closing date does not always create a default deadline. The consequences change when time becomes essential.
Determine Whether Time Is of the Essence
The contract may state that time is of the essence. If it does not, a party may later serve a valid notice fixing a firm closing date. The notice must be clear, provide reasonable time to perform, and communicate that missing the deadline will constitute default.
There is no universally valid notice period. Courts examine extensions, unresolved title issues, conduct, and hardship. An ordinary scheduling email may not suffice. A notice sent to the wrong address or recipient can also raise a problem if the contract specifies how notice must be delivered.
Preserve Proof before Responding
A buyer receiving a firm notice should check financing and closing documents. Ignoring it may put the deposit at risk. Preserve:
- The notice and proof of how it was delivered.
- Mortgage approvals, bank records, and required closing funds.
- Written extensions, title objections, and responses from the seller.
Follow the required notice method. These statewide principles also arise in transactions discussed in residential real estate lawyer in NYC, although local recording offices differ.
4. What Remedies Are Available If the Seller Defaults?

Possible remedies include a refund, damages, or an order requiring the sale. Contract terms may limit them.
Compare a Refund, Damages, and Specific Performance
A refund returns the deposit, not the home. Damages require proof of a legally recoverable loss and any contractual limits. Not every added expense qualifies. Inspection costs, moving expenses, and the claimed loss of the bargain require separate legal analysis.
Specific performance asks the court to order the sale. The buyer generally must establish an enforceable contract, seller default, and readiness and ability to close, subject to equitable considerations. The court also considers whether a money award would adequately address the harm. An exclusive-refund clause may change the outcome, particularly if it distinguishes a title problem from willful default.
Identify the Suffolk County Filing Route
CPLR § 507 generally places actions affecting land in the county where it lies. A Suffolk County buyer may seek specific performance in Supreme Court under applicable procedural rules.
CPLR § 6501 permits a notice of pendency for qualifying claims affecting property interests, not merely a money demand. Suffolk County generally requires NYSCEF electronic filing in civil cases, with exceptions.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Seller Accept a Higher Offer After Signing a Contract?
A higher offer does not cancel an enforceable contract. A seller may consider a backup, but refusal to honor the first sale may be a breach. Keep messages showing any refusal. A backup offer by itself is different from a definite statement that the seller will not close.
Can the Buyer Recover Attorney Fees After a Seller's Breach?
Not automatically. New York generally requires a contract, statute, or court rule authorizing fee recovery. A prevailing-party clause must cover the dispute. Recovering the deposit alone does not establish a fee claim.
6. What Should a Buyer Bring to a Legal Review?
For a Suffolk County residential purchase dispute, bring the signed agreement, riders, deposit receipt, title objections, notices, and seller's responses. Identify the next deadline and deposit holder. SJKP LLP's attorneys can assess whether a written demand, settlement, or court claim has a legal basis.
18 Nov, 2026

