1. Which Property Rights Are in Conflict?
A sale may stall even when the seller owns the property. An unreleased mortgage, a competing deed, or a tenant's right to remain presents a different problem. Identifying the disputed right helps determine which documents and legal services the matter requires.
Ownership Claims and Title Defects
Two deeds may appear to transfer the same interest, or a signature may raise questions about the seller's authority. Recording an instrument does not, by itself, resolve a competing claim to title.
- Compare parties, signatures, dates, and property descriptions.
- Review earlier transfers and possible gaps in the chain of title.
- Identify anyone who may assert an adverse interest.
Liens, Mortgages, and Occupancy
A mortgage secures a debt, while a lease generally grants possession rather than ownership. Their effects on a sale or continued occupancy depend on the documents and applicable law.
| Concern | Key Question |
|---|---|
| Mortgage or lien | Is it outstanding, satisfied, or disputed? |
| Lease or occupancy | Who has the right to remain, and under what terms? |
| Competing deed | Which transfer and claimed interest need review? |
Mortgage or lien
- Key QuestionIs it outstanding, satisfied, or disputed?
Lease or occupancy
- Key QuestionWho has the right to remain, and under what terms?
Competing deed
- Key QuestionWhich transfer and claimed interest need review?
2. What Should a Property Case Review Compare?
A useful case review compares recorded instruments with the contracts and communications behind them. Public records may show a lien without establishing whether the debt remains unpaid. Later payments, notices, and deadlines can change the legal options.
Recording History and Title Materials
New York City's Automated City Register Information System (ACRIS) provides access to recorded Manhattan deeds and mortgages. A public-record search does not replace a complete title examination.
- Verify the borough, block, and lot before searching.
- Compare deeds and mortgages with the title report.
- Look for satisfactions, releases, and unexplained gaps.
Contracts, Surveys, and Notices
A deed may not reveal a boundary dispute or an unmet contract condition. In real estate transactions, purchase terms and notice provisions may determine which response is available.
- Read contingencies, default provisions, and written amendments.
- Compare surveys with recorded legal descriptions.
- Keep notices and records showing when they were delivered.
3. Can the Problem Be Resolved without Litigation?

A paid mortgage may still appear on the record because no satisfaction was recorded. A competing deed or disputed occupancy cannot necessarily be resolved that way. The first question is whether the parties need a document correction or a determination of their rights.
Releases and Contested Title
An outstanding mortgage may call for a recorded satisfaction or release. When another party asserts an adverse interest, an action under RPAPL Article 15, often called a quiet title action, may be available if the statutory requirements are met.
- Identify the recorded claim affecting title.
- Ask whether a valid release or correction is possible.
- Assess court relief if adverse claims remain contested.
Defaults and Possession Disagreements
A missed rent payment or disputed lease expiration does not authorize a landlord to remove an occupant without lawful process. The tenancy, notices, and asserted grounds determine which possession proceeding may be available.
- Review the lease, payment history, and alleged breach.
- Check applicable notice and service requirements.
- Distinguish negotiation from a court-ordered possession remedy.
4. Which New York Records and Courts Apply?
Public records help identify a property issue, but they cannot decide who owns a disputed interest. The available remedy determines the next forum. A recording problem may call for an administrative or documentary correction, while ownership or possession claims can require court proceedings.
Recording Problems and Supporting Evidence
ACRIS includes online records dating from 1966. Older records may require a search through the City Register's research library. Building records address different questions, such as permits or violations, and do not establish title.
- Identify the instrument and its recording information.
- Obtain missing documents when the online record is incomplete.
- Separate recording issues from ownership or building disputes.
Possession Cases and Title Actions
New York City Civil Court hears residential and commercial landlord-tenant matters, though their court parts differ. Actions to determine adverse claims under RPAPL Article 15 generally proceed in New York Supreme Court. Other real estate litigation may involve distinct remedies and procedures.
- Identify whether the claim concerns possession, title, or damages.
- Read filed papers for court dates and response requirements.
- Consider whether separate claims need different proceedings.
5. Frequently Asked Questions about Real Estate Attorneys
How much does a real estate lawyer cost in NYC?
Fees depend on the documents, the contested issues, and whether court proceedings are involved. Ask what the proposed fee covers and how additional work is billed.
Can title insurance help if someone challenges ownership?
It may, depending on the policy and its exclusions. Review notice requirements and whether the insurer has a duty to defend the particular claim.
Can a title problem affect refinancing before a dispute is resolved?
Yes. A lender may require clarification of an apparent lien or ownership discrepancy. The documents and lender's requirements determine what further review is needed.
6. Discuss Your Property Rights with SJKP
SJKP's attorneys can examine deeds, contracts, and notices to discuss the rights in question and the scope of representation. When contacting the firm, identify the disputed instrument, the other party's position, and any approaching deadline. The review can clarify whether a document correction, negotiation, or court claim merits further consideration.
16 Nov, 2026

