1. Local Records Establish Different Property Rights

A purchase requires separate checks of recorded ownership, authorized use, and actual occupancy. One report cannot answer all three.
Deeds and Title Exceptions Reveal Competing Interests
The Assessor-Recorder maintains deeds, liens, and reconveyances. Compare the legal description with the preliminary title report and examine exceptions for loans, easements, or restrictions. A preliminary report offers insurance on stated terms, not proof of clear ownership. Review exclusions in the owner's title insurance policy before closing.
A 3R Report Tests the Advertised Unit Count
San Francisco Housing Code § 351 generally requires sellers of covered residential buildings to obtain and deliver a Report of Residential Building Record (3R) before sale. Buyers must file the prescribed receipt with the Department of Building Inspection (DBI).
If a listing advertises three units but the 3R identifies two authorized dwellings, investigate before closing. A 3R draws on city records, excludes plumbing and electrical permit histories, and is not an inspection or proof of code compliance.
Permit Records Cannot Replace an Inspection
The city's Property Information Map displays zoning, permits, complaints, and appeals. DBI records may reveal authorized alterations, but neither source establishes concealed structural conditions or proves that work matches approved plans. Further inspection may be needed.
2. Ownership Structure and Closing Terms Define the Deal
Buyers must establish what interest transfers, what obligations accompany it, and how the contract handles unresolved findings.
TIC Ownership Differs from Condominium Title
A tenancy-in-common (TIC) buyer holds an undivided share in a parcel. Exclusive occupancy generally rests on a co-ownership agreement, not separate condominium title. Examine repair costs, payment defaults, occupancy rights, and loans. San Francisco generally issues one property-tax bill for the TIC parcel, making co-owner contributions important. Condominium units instead have separate parcels and governing documents.
Closing Conditions Must Address Unresolved Findings
A disputed unit count calls for a written response, not a verbal promise. Examine contingencies, escrow instructions, and deadlines before requesting a permit investigation, extension, or revised condition. The general real estate transfer process covers contract-to-recording steps. Here the issue is whether local records contradict the property being purchased.
Transfer Tax Does Not Cure a Title Problem
San Francisco Business and Tax Regulations Code Article 12-C imposes documentary transfer tax on covered transfers, subject to exemptions. The Assessor-Recorder handles recording and collection. Review the tax affidavit and contract allocation of costs. Payment and recording do not clear liens or authorize additional units.
3. Tenant Occupancy Can Outlast the Sale
Purchasing a rented building does not automatically end existing tenancies. Check each lease and the applicable housing rules before expecting vacant possession.
A Vacant-Delivery Clause Is Not an Eviction Order
Compare leases, amendments, rent records, and occupants with the purchase agreement. San Francisco Administrative Code § 37.9 restricts eviction grounds for units under its just-cause provisions. Sale alone does not authorize removal of a covered tenant. Identify the seller's duties if possession remains disputed. Existing residential lease terms may bind the buyer.
Ownership Changes Trigger Separate Notices
For units subject to § 37.9, sellers must disclose tenant rights before sale. Under § 37.9(k)(2), purchasers must give tenants a separate written notice within 30 days after acquiring title. It addresses occupancy, rent restrictions, lease terms, and housing services.
San Francisco's Rent Board Housing Inventory generally requires annual residential-property reporting by March 1, including vacant and owner-occupied units. Certain rent increases require a rent increase license.
4. Practical Pitfalls Determine the Next Procedure
A discrepancy may require a contract notice, agency inquiry, or lawsuit. The route depends on the violated right and applicable deadlines.
Permit Requests Do Not Extend Contract Deadlines
A buyer may await DBI records when a contingency expires. Preserve the contract, disclosure receipts, inspection reports, escrow messages, and delivery evidence. Seek extensions in the required form. Separate California real estate attorney guidance covers default and cancellation disputes. Informal negotiations do not necessarily preserve notice rights.
Administrative Enforcement Is Not Contract Relief
DBI and Planning address building and land-use issues, while the Rent Board handles matters within its authority. They do not necessarily decide deposit claims. Ownership and contract disputes may require proceedings in San Francisco Superior Court or contractually required dispute resolution. An attorney can distinguish agency compliance from a civil claim, evaluate evidence, and draft appropriate notices.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
How Much Does a Real Estate Lawyer Cost in California?
Fees depend on document volume, negotiations, and potential litigation. Ask about hourly or fixed fees, scope, and separate expenses. California Business and Professions Code § 6148 generally requires a written agreement for qualifying noncontingent matters when foreseeable fees and costs exceed $1,000, subject to exceptions.
When Should a Buyer Hire a Real Estate Attorney?
Seek review before signing a complex TIC agreement, waiving contingencies, or closing with unresolved occupancy issues. If a dispute exists, bring the signed agreement, notices, and relevant deadlines.
Does an Unpermitted Unit Automatically Allow a Deposit Refund?
No. Examine seller representations, applicable disclosures, contractual contingencies, and notice requirements. A 3R discrepancy calls for investigation but does not itself create a cancellation or refund right.
16 Nov, 2026

