East Hampton Real Estate Lawyer Reviews Permit Risks before Closing

Practice Area:Real Estate
Jurisdiction:New York

An East Hampton real estate lawyer explains why the Town's 2026 CO enforcement pause does not waive a seller's contractual duties.

Town Code § 102-14(A) generally requires an updated certificate of occupancy (CO) when ownership changes. Enforcement is paused through December 31, 2026, but construction and Village requirements remain separate.



1. Which Municipality Controls the Property's Permits?


A mailing address does not establish building jurisdiction. The parcel's location determines which department handles permits and whether the Town's enforcement pause applies.


Confirm the Town or Village Boundary

The Village of East Hampton has its own building regulations. Part of Sag Harbor Village also lies within East Hampton Town. Village Code § 104-11(A) separately regulates occupancy after an ownership change. The Town's enforcement pause does not suspend that requirement. Use the parcel's tax map number to identify the responsible Building Department and request certificates, permits, and violation records.

Compare Existing Structures with Approved Plans

A survey may show a pool, deck, or addition missing from approved plans. Zoning may limit height, setbacks, building coverage, or use. Wetland and coastal rules can restrict improvements, while work affecting regulated waters may require federal authorization under Clean Water Act § 404. Compare the survey with approved permits. Applicable real estate regulations determine whether proposed work needs a permit, variance, or environmental approval.


2. What Does the 2026 CO Enforcement Pause Cover?


Diagram: Three categories compare the paused transfer CO requirement with construction and occupancy rules that remain in effect.
Diagram: Three categories compare the paused transfer CO requirement with construction and occupancy rules that remain in effect.

On March 10, 2026, the Town approved an enforcement stay for updated COs required upon ownership transfers. The stay is retroactive to January 1, 2024, and is scheduled to expire on December 31, 2026, unless extended.


Understand the Transfer CO Requirement

Town Code § 102-14(A) includes exceptions for transfers with an updated CO obtained within the preceding six months and qualifying estate-planning transfers that preserve beneficial ownership. During the stay, the Town will not issue a violation solely for a missing updated transfer CO. The Building Department continues accepting applications. The requirement remains in the code, so buyers closing near the expiration date should confirm the current enforcement policy.

Distinguish Unapproved Construction from the Transfer Requirement

Sections 102-14(B) and (C) separately address occupancy following construction requiring a building permit and changes in use or occupancy. An open permit, unauthorized addition, or converted garage may still require corrective work. An earlier CO does not establish that later renovations were approved. Compare the building's current condition with approved plans and resolve outstanding permits where required.


3. Can Unresolved Permits Delay a Property Closing?


Yes. The purchase contract determines whether a missing approval requires correction, allows an extension, or supports termination. The parties must follow the agreed conditions and deadlines.


Identify the Seller's Written Obligations

New York General Obligations Law § 5-703(2) generally requires a signed writing for an enforceable real property sale agreement, subject to recognized exceptions. The contract may require a CO, correction of violations, or completed repairs. Review the agreement for:

  • Required permits and certificates.
  • Seller statements about improvements.
  • Closing conditions and correction deadlines.
  • Notice and termination provisions.

The real estate transfer process must account for these conditions. A municipal enforcement decision does not amend the signed agreement.

Address Missing Approvals before the Closing Deadline

If the seller lacks a required approval, the parties may agree in writing to repairs, expenses, or a closing extension. An escrow arrangement may be possible with the parties' and lender's consent, but it does not legalize unauthorized construction. Before demanding cancellation or a deposit refund, review termination rights, notice requirements, and opportunities to cure. A missed closing date does not automatically establish a breach. The contract and the parties' performance determine the available response.

Match the Defect to the Correct Action

Each defect requires a different record and response.

Closing IssueRecord to ExaminePossible Response
Unapproved additionPermit file and plansSeek approval or correction
Open building permitInspection historyComplete required closeout
Missing promised COContract and CO recordsResolve the closing condition
Boundary discrepancySurvey and deedInvestigate the difference

Unapproved addition

  • Record to ExaminePermit file and plans
  • Possible ResponseSeek approval or correction

Open building permit

  • Record to ExamineInspection history
  • Possible ResponseComplete required closeout

Missing promised CO

  • Record to ExamineContract and CO records
  • Possible ResponseResolve the closing condition

Boundary discrepancy

  • Record to ExamineSurvey and deed
  • Possible ResponseInvestigate the difference

Record any agreed repairs, expenses, and deadlines in writing rather than relying on verbal promises.


4. What Other Records Matter before Closing?


Building compliance, transfer taxes, and ownership rights involve different requirements. Buyers should verify each before accepting the closing documents.


Calculate the Local Transfer Tax

Town Code § 112-2-20 generally imposes a 2.5% tax on taxable consideration, including 2% for community preservation and 0.5% for community housing. Section 112-2-40 allows qualifying deductions of $400,000 for improved property or $100,000 for unimproved land. Neither applies to conveyances of $2 million or more. The buyer generally pays under § 112-2-30, although the seller may become liable in certain circumstances, including the buyer's failure to pay. New York State transfer taxes are separate. Confirm applicable exemptions and payment duties before closing.

Check Recorded Ownership Interests

The Suffolk County Clerk maintains deeds, mortgages, easements, and recorded satisfactions. A title report may reveal interests affecting the property. Under Real Property Law § 291, recording can affect priority against qualifying later purchasers. Review deed recording requirements, but remember that recording a deed does not cure unapproved construction.


5. Frequently Asked Questions


Can a Mortgage Lender Require a CO During the 2026 Pause?

Yes. A lender may request a CO, proof of completed permits, or inspection documents before releasing funds. The Town's enforcement pause does not waive private lending requirements. Check the loan commitment before agreeing to close without these documents.

Does Title Insurance Cover Unpermitted Construction?

Not necessarily. Standard title policies generally exclude many zoning, building code, and permit violations. Some endorsements may cover specific risks, depending on the policy terms and exclusions. Title insurance does not ordinarily pay to legalize an unauthorized addition discovered after closing.



6. Review Closing Documents with SJKP LLP


A buyer facing an open permit, missing CO, or unapproved improvement should identify the applicable municipal rule and contract deadline. SJKP LLP's attorneys can review agreements, surveys, title reports, and permit records to assess available legal options. Contact SJKP LLP to discuss the documents and scope of legal review before closing.


20 Nov, 2026


The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Reading or relying on the contents of this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm. For advice regarding your specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
Certain informational content on this website may utilize technology-assisted drafting tools and is subject to attorney review.

Related practices