1. Is the Property within a Designated Historic District?
Landmark rules depend on the property's designation and when the work occurred. A Park Slope address alone does not establish coverage.
Confirm the Boundary and Designation Date
The original Park Slope Historic District was designated on July 17, 1973, with extensions on April 17, 2012, and April 12, 2016. Compare the address, block, and lot with LPC's designation map. Work completed before designation does not violate later landmark rules solely because the property became protected. Later changes to older work may still need LPC approval. Building and zoning rules may also apply.
Identify Work Requiring LPC Approval
NYC Administrative Code § 25-305 generally requires prior approval for covered alterations. Section 25-310 addresses regulated minor work. Window changes, stoop work, and roof additions may require approval, even when hidden from the street. Replacing broken glass in kind generally does not. Rooftop projects may also face land use and zoning restrictions.
2. Which Records Prove That Renovation Work Was Approved?

A finished renovation is not proof of city approval. Compare the actual work with issued permits and approved drawings.
Check the Permit Type and Approved Scope
LPC chooses the permit based on the proposed work.
| LPC Permit | Typical Use | Reviewer |
|---|---|---|
| Certificate of No Effect (CNE) | Work needing a DOB permit without an adverse effect on protected features | LPC staff |
| Permit for Minor Work (PMW) | Eligible exterior work not requiring a DOB permit | LPC staff |
| Certificate of Appropriateness (CofA) | Changes needing Commission review | Commission after a public hearing |
Certificate of No Effect (CNE)
- Typical UseWork needing a DOB permit without an adverse effect on protected features
- ReviewerLPC staff
Permit for Minor Work (PMW)
- Typical UseEligible exterior work not requiring a DOB permit
- ReviewerLPC staff
Certificate of Appropriateness (CofA)
- Typical UseChanges needing Commission review
- ReviewerCommission after a public hearing
An application or Commission vote is not necessarily an issued permit. Check conditions and amendments. A permit for windows does not authorize a rear extension. Match the approved drawings and scope to the actual work.
Search Recent and Older LPC Records
LPC's Permit Application Finder covers applications and permits since January 1, 2016. Request older records separately. An empty search does not prove that approval was absent. The map shows active violations and violations rescinded since January 1, 2020. Older violations may not appear there. Photographs or invoices may help date the work but cannot replace agency records.
Compare LPC Approvals with DOB Filings
LPC reviews landmark features. The Department of Buildings (DOB) enforces separate building requirements. Check BIS and DOB NOW for permits, violations, and sign-offs. Approval from one agency does not replace the other's required permit. Unresolved construction filing issues may affect a planned renovation or closing. For an enclosed roof area or additional unit, confirm legal occupancy as well as exterior approval.
3. Can an Earlier Owner's Violation Affect the Buyer?
Yes. An unresolved violation may remain active against the property after a sale, but a prior owner's personal penalties do not automatically transfer.
Check Warnings and Summonses
Obtain warning letters, summonses, and correction records. Confirm the cited work and current enforcement status. Under 63 RCNY § 11-04, most Warning Letter recipients have 20 working days from the letter's date to correct the condition or submit an application to address it. Filing does not itself close the violation. LPC may issue a summons for an OATH hearing if the matter remains unresolved. Payment of a fine may leave the corrective duty outstanding. Request proof that LPC has resolved the violation rather than relying on the seller's statement.
Determine Whether the Work Can Stay
Some unauthorized work may receive approval after completion. Other work requires changes or removal, generally under an LPC permit. After correction, LPC may require a Notice of Compliance. Before closing, determine what work remains and who will bear the cost. An architect may need to assess structural changes.
4. How Should the Contract Address Missing Permits?
A missing permit does not automatically allow cancellation or a deposit refund. The signed contract and applicable New York law govern those remedies.
Set Specific Seller Obligations
A promise to "resolve permits" leaves too much uncertain. The agreement should state:
- Which alteration or violation needs attention.
- Who applies for approval and pays the costs.
- Which LPC or DOB document proves completion.
- The deadline and response to rejection or delay.
If the seller promises to finish after closing, specify access, payment, and what happens if the work stalls. The lender may request separate records before funding.
Plan for Delay or Rejection
The parties may negotiate a closing extension, seller-funded repairs, a price adjustment, or an escrow arrangement. Escrow terms should state when funds may be released. Escrow does not replace city approval. Under New York General Obligations Law § 5-703, a real property sale agreement or sufficient memorandum generally must be written and signed by the party to be charged. Material changes should be documented in signed writing. LPC and DOB decide regulatory compliance, not contract remedies. Other New York real estate law issues may affect closing. Buyers comparing states should distinguish New York requirements from those discussed in this real estate attorney near me in CA guide. California property-rights procedures do not govern an NYC landmark permit issue.
5. Frequently Asked Questions
Does Title Insurance Cover an Unpermitted Roof Deck?
Usually not the cost of correcting unauthorized work. Standard policies generally exclude building and zoning violations, subject to policy terms and covered-risk exceptions. Review exclusions, endorsements, and any coverage for a separate title defect before relying on the policy.
How Much Does a Real Estate Attorney Charge for Landmark Permit Review?
Fees vary. A routine purchase may carry a flat fee, while permit research or negotiations may cost extra. Request written terms covering agency searches, contract revisions, and additional charges. Ask whether an architect's report or permit-expediter fee is separate.
6. Review Landmark Permit Issues with SJKP LLP
SJKP LLP's attorneys can assess LPC and DOB records, unresolved violations, and contract provisions. A Park Slope real estate attorney can explain approval steps and the buyer's options before signing.
20 Nov, 2026

